| Year |
Name |
| 1985 | MONA LEWIS |
| 1986 | CLAY HILSABECK |
| 1987 | KARLA FERGUSON |
| 1988 | TAMI OFFENBACKER |
| 1989 | SANDY DEFFENBAUGH |
| 1990 | SHANNON GALBREATH, JANICE BELCHER |
| 1991 | LISA GRISHOW |
| 1992 | BOBBIE BARBO |
| 1993 | SCOTT WILSON |
| 1994 | DONITA HUFFAKER |
| 1995 | TERRY SYBERT |
| 1996 | SANDY CAMPBELL |
| 1997 | JAMIE SMITH |
| 1998 | APRIL HOUSE |
| 1999 | KATIE NIE |
| 2000 | TONY ATKINS |
| 2001 | LESLEE KAMMERER |
| 2002 | JOSEPH KENNEDY |
| 2003 | STACY TAYLOR |
| 2004 | DYAN SYBERT |
| 2005 | CHAIM JENKINS |
| Year |
Name |
| 2006 | MADISON CHAMBERS |
| 2007 | LINDSAY HUGHES |
| 2008 | JACOB PITTMAN |
| 2009 | KENDRA HUGHES |
| 2010 | HAYLEY GRIMES |
| 2011 | BLAISE HECKMAN |
| 2012 | TYLER SMITH |
| 2013 | COLIN ROUSH |
| 2021 | EMALEE PITTMAN |
| 2023 | EMILY MANNING |